[ Book Review ] The Throne of Fire by Rick Riordan

Throne of Fire by Rick Riordan

Book Two of the Kane Chronicles

Throne of Fire is Rick Riordan’s second book in the Kane Chronicles and it picks up just a few weeks after The Red Pyramid. Carter and Sadie are back in action…along with the majority of the Egyptian pantheon, most of the Egyptian sorcerers, and all of the forces of evil. The Kane kids are convinced that the only way to stop the world from falling to chaos is to wake the sleeping sun god, Ra. Everyone who’s anyone in the Egyptian pantheon thinks that’s a terrible idea.

I’ve never known enough about Egyptian mythology to make a call about whether or not their plan makes sense. The way it’s presented throughout the story seems to jive with my view of the cosmos–a central figure who represents order (plus supporting cast) is opposed by a bad guy who represents chaos and all things evil. In the universe of the Kane Chronicles, your order guy has been asleep for a long time and needs someone to wind up his alarm clock. Fine, I can go with that.

Of course, it’s not that simple and the kids deal with lots of “what if’s”, “what then’s”, and “oh crap, this other god figure who’s really ticked about losing power is going to eat us now.”

The narration wastes no time in leaping directly into the shenanigans; the characters introduce themselves in the midst of a night-time museum break-in caper—a museum that happens to be hosting a wedding reception. But really, what wedding reception is complete without a group of flaming plague spirits running amok amongst the bridesmaids?

True to Kane tradition, in the midst of the heist (which serves as an excellent way to introduce new characters and their abilities) Sadie and Carter receive an ominous warning, and we’re off at a breakneck pace that rarely slows to less than a sprint. Even moments of introspection and character growth are delivered in true teenage fashion: Retrospective one-liners are almost apologetic and, more often than not, belligerent as the character is forced (kicking and screaming, or as they’re dragged away by an ancient demon) to acknowledge that some of the less admirable situations are entirely of their own making.

The way the narration was set up, with small breaks in the story flow as the siblings bicker with one another over who can speak into the recorder, made Sadie and Carter even more three dimensional. This was a real teenage brother and sister poking at how annoying the other can be. The inter-adventure moments of “I shoulda seen that coming” add that great touch of humor to the story.

Even with outstanding humor and every action sequence propelling you through the story,  Throne of Fire is a second book.

Second books are often a bit like the awkward adolescent years of pimples, cracking voices and trying to understand what the heck is going on down there… ahem. The point is, I could really feel the novel’s growing pains.

After an eternity of pain, fights, loss, sacrifice and “girl likes boy but boy might like someone else”, “boy likes girl but girl is hosting an Egyptian river goddess and currently in suspended animation in a hidden tomb”, and “girl likes boy but also has a thing for the ancient Egyptian god of funerals” drama, the characters kinda win.

KINDA win?

I did not go through chapters of “OMG, he’s really hot, but sometimes he has a jackal head” issues to get a KINDA victory.

I understand that this is just one adventure within the greater story–one battle in the war–but there was no resolution at the end of my candy corn adventure! I want a resolution!

I want the decisive victory–or at least one real victory in the manifold of issues facing the heroes. I can think of no less than ten problems that our heroes are dealing with and not  a single one was solved to my satisfaction. I seriously can’t come up with a PG sentence to vent my frustration, and I’m considering severing a lot of canaries in my rating.

Can I just give halves? Is that legit? If I give 5 halves–does that mean I like it a lot, but it really ticks me off? I don’t like the ending, I wasn’t satisfied. It doesn’t feel like a happy ending or even the close of an adventure. It feels like a hook for a “buy my next book.”

Excellent story, great characters, phenomenal action and humor, fun and fun and fun and lovable,–blew the dismount.

6 thoughts on “[ Book Review ] The Throne of Fire by Rick Riordan

  1. It’s tempting to say that a disappointing ending would be the same as a disappointing couple of chapters in an otherwise good book — but that’s total bs — it’s the ENDING!

    The Illearth War (nearly the book I chose as favorite book when I did my post) was the second book in the Chronicle of Thomas Covenant by Stephen Donaldson. Awesome book — gripping and heartbreaking and there IS a conclusion even though it’s the middle book. It’s not the be-all-end-all ending, but it’s satisfying for the book and makes you want to read the finale. And everyone knows The Empire Strikes Back with its we-survived-to-fight-another-day ending was the most satisfying Star Wars film of all.

  2. Pingback: [ Pitch Slapped ] Huh? « thecanaryreview

  3. Pingback: [Book Review] If they cast Nina Dobrev as Number Seven, I’m in. « thecanaryreview

  4. Pingback: [Book Review] Kane Chronicles Closure « thecanaryreview

Chirp! What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s